Information Warfare Article Index : Current 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
 Latest
 News
 
 Most
 Read
 
 Most
 Commented
 Hot
 Topics
Sticking By The Official Lie
   Next Article → COUNTER-TERRORISM: Al Qaeda And The Pride Divide
June 30, 2010: Recently, an article appeared in a Chinese magazine describing the beginning of the Korean war, sixty years earlier. What was unusual about the article, in a government approved publication, was the frank admission that North Korea had started it all, by invading South Korea. But once news of the article spread, and was posted on Internet sites, the Chinese government ordered the article withdrawn, and denounced it as untrue. The unofficial reason was that China wished to avoid angering North Korea. This, despite the fact that Chinese participation in the war killed or wounded over half a million Chinese. Even Chinese leader Mao Tedong lost a son in Korea.

Since 1950, it had been the official Chinese position that the war started with a South Korean invasion of the north, to which the north responded by moving into South Korea. For decades, all communist nations accepted this version, even though all evidence pointed towards the north invading first. Then, in the 1990s, the Russian government released telegrams sent before 1960, by Russian and North Korean leaders, making it clear that Russia wanted the invasion, and that North Korea duly carried it out.

Chinese troops entered North Korea in late 1950, to prevent American forces from occupying all of Korea, and that resulted in a three year stalemate along the current inter-Korean border (the DMZ, or Demilitarized Zone). Over 200,000 Chinese died in the war, in addition to half a million North Koreans, two million South Koreans and 37,000 UN troops (over 90 percent of them American). To justify the losses, and maintain good relations with North Korea, China continued to insist that South Korea had started the war, even after everyone agreed that Russian leader Josef Stalin and North Korea had been the instigators.

What this incident really tells North Korea is that China has admitted the truth about who started the war (by authorizing the article's publication in the first place), but is so sorry for this accident and officially sticks by the earlier lie.

 

 

Next Article → COUNTER-TERRORISM: Al Qaeda And The Pride Divide
  

Show Only Poster Name and Title     Newest to Oldest
trenchsol       6/30/2010 7:19:01 PM
At the end of Korean War there were many Chinese POW who didn't want to go home. China insisted that all POW's need to be returned, especially those who didn't want to be repatriated. Does anyone know what was their fate ?

DG
 
Quote    Reply

Photon       7/1/2010 12:35:30 PM
I do not think there has been that much said about Chicom POWs who have repatriated back to PRC.  Instead, most of things written about were from those who have joined Taiwan.
 
Back in mid 1951, when the cease-fire negotiation was getting started, perhaps the most contentious issue was the issue over prisoner repatriation.  The Communists wanted repatriations, while the UN wanted prisoners to choose their destination.  This alone might have prolonged the war.  (Off-topic:  Another contentious issue was about the cease-fire line.  The Communists wanted to go back to the pre-war 38th parallel, while the UN wanted the current frontline -- which was more defensible and the South gained a bit more territory compared to the pre-war border arrangement.)
 
How contentious was this prisoner repatriation could be glimpsed by taking a look at Sygman Rhee (the ROK president back then).  He wanted to unify the peninsula and was not above resorting to brinkmanship, but this would be possible only if the war dragged on.  He deliberately provoked the Communists in 1953 by releasing North Korean prisoners and many of them chose to stay in the South.  Of course, this pissed off the Communists.  But by then, both the US and China were no longer enthusiastic about prolonging the war.
 
Quote    Reply