The Strategypage is a comprehensive summary of military news and affairs.
 News As History - November 23, 2008

Dunnigan's and Bay's Latest

Advertisement



New Strategy - Wargames at Discount Prices
1.Squad Battles: Winter War
2.Silent War
3.Manoeuvre
4.Gallic Wars
5.Fast Action Battle: The Bulge

100+ Computer and Board games all with free shipping.
 
 
 

Online Giving

Utah SEO Firm

Xango

Smiley Gifts for Babies

Military History | How To Make War | Wars Around the World Rules of Use
Artillery Discussion Board
Sign In   Return to Topic Page
Subject: Towed Artillery Displacement times
FD    7/18/2007 10:25:46 AM
What would be an average time for a towed battery of 8 to tear down to move to an alternate location? I can't find a standard time for this event. Assume a non-digitized battery with wire connections over a 300m area. I'm assuming they could move at least 700m in about 2 mintues once they are packed up but I'm not sure how long it would take to tear down after the last shot. Thanks.
 
Quote    Reply
 Latest
 News
 
 Most
 Read
 
 Most
 Commented
 Hot
 Topics

Email Me When A New Comment Is Made
Show Only Poster Name and Title     Sort in Reverse Order Posted

Carl S       7/18/2007 11:59:55 AM
This has probablly be discussed here before, but its faster for me to look it up.

From the US 'Marine Corps Combat Readyness Evaluation Standards' book circa 1987.

Task 5A,1,23 Conduct An Emergency Displacement

Items .3 and  .4 state:  ...all howitzers... mission essential equipment must be displaced 200 meters within three minutes.

That was nt at all difficult for us to accomplish with the old M101 or M102 105mm howitzers, the M114 155mm towed howitzer, or the various self propelled cannon.  With the eight ton M198 (155mm) that replaced all those on the USMC gun park it took closer to five minutes to limber the beast.

Of course someone would have to return to recover whatever the enemy had left you in the old position : )

Back in the six gun battery days we did ordinary displacements in stages.  An advance party would leave at least a quarter hour before the battery was expected to displace.  The Adv Pty would usually take one or two cannon with them to provide emergency suppresion fires when the main body moved.  A quarter hour or so   before displacement a signal would be give to secure all non mission essential equipment, working partys would return to their sections, some vehicals move to the road,  cammoflage removed if possible...  When the final order for "March Order" was given five to ten minutes were sufficent for limbering the cannon and loading the remaining equipment.  Some times a rear party would remain to complete repairs on a vehical, load extra ammo,  or other tasks. 

With the eight cannon batterys we usually moved by platoons.  Each platoon displaced much the same as the six cannon battery, except the advance party did not take a howitzer with them.  The remaining platoon would usually not displace untill the first was mission ready in its new position.

Under ideal conditions, such as on hard clear desert or grassland surface a battery or platoon could displace in as little as five minutes, less in a emergency.  On difficult ground like the rice paddys of Korea, the snow filled woods of Minninnesota, or in mud ten minutes or more is closer.
 
Quote    Reply

FD       7/18/2007 3:37:28 PM
Thanks for the info. I was wondering if it took a long time or not.
 
Quote    Reply

Carl S       7/18/2007 6:19:38 PM
It can if the battery crew are drilled wrong.  Either some slacker thrid world army, or lead by a third rate officer.  I've seen & been in a few batterys that were an embarasment.  Also on some training days theres no deadline & the commander will slow things down for one or another reason.
 
Quote    Reply

neutralizer       7/19/2007 5:07:29 AM
You mean there are armies so backward that they aren't digitised and use wire comms?
 
Like all these things it depends.  Obviously larger guns take longer to bring out of action than smaller ones. Other factors are:
The time between 'Prepare to Move' and 'Cease Firing'.  This 'window' is when ammo and stores are repacked, less the essentials to remain in action, and cam taken down and packed. 
Next is whether towing vehicles are kept alongside the guns or eleswhere and at what stage they are brought up to the guns. 
 
From cease firing to hooked up and loaded, shouldn't take more than a couple of minutes but is does depend on where the towing and ammo vehicles were when 'Cease Firing' was ordered and how much ammo there is to load.  Also whether its on pallets, boxed or loose.  If on pallets it also depends how good the RTFLs (eg can they load two deep from one side) and their operators are, and to what extent this activity can start before 'Cease Firing'.
 
Non digitised means traditional orientation by director/aiming circle and dial sight/pantel.  8 Guns can be a bit of a challenge and finding reasonable tactical gun positions for a battery of this size that can orient from a single instrument is not always easy.  I'd suggest at least10 minutes in daylight by the time a check bearing has been completed, probably longer if you don't have radio between instrument and guns, but radioless guns positions diasppeared decades ago.  Given digital sighs its more like 60 seconds and probably waiting for the CP computer to re-boot! (unless you've got a modern one).
 
Quote    Reply

FD       7/19/2007 8:06:21 AM
Thanks,  I'm looking at the M119A2 105mm  the only non-digitized howitzer in the Army inventory. I assmue they still run wire. I don't have an artillery back ground but we were discussing it at work. One of my colleagues said that packing up within two minutes was possible. We were discussing quick firing for the M119A2, where they just pull off the road, setup and fire; then quickly recover. I know the standard is 11 minutes for setup but no recover time was given.
 
Quote    Reply

FD       7/19/2007 1:11:35 PM
Thanks,  I'm looking at the M119A2 105mm  the only non-digitized howitzer in the Army inventory. I assmue they still run wire. I don't have an artillery back ground but we were discussing it at work. One of my colleagues said that packing up within two minutes was possible. We were discussing quick firing for the M119A2, where they just pull off the road, setup and fire; then quickly recover. I know the standard is 11 minutes for setup but no recover time was given.
 
Quote    Reply

Carl S       7/19/2007 7:58:45 PM
I wonder what is defined by "setup time".   Time to emplace & lay a M101 battery is eight minutes in my old MCCRES book.  There must be other steps included in the 11 minutes.

Unfortunatly my old copy does not include a standard for a emergency 'hip shoot' misson from a road march.  I've seen claims from Britsh artillerymen of times as low as 90 seconds to unlimber & lay the cannon.  For us, from initial radio order to first shot down range was a bit over five minutes if my dim memory serves.  However laying with a section chiefs compass in a unsurveyed position made accuraccy a bit problematic.
 
Quote    Reply

neutralizer       7/20/2007 3:16:47 AM
First point is it depends whether the barrel is in the A frame or reversed, if the latter add 30-45 sec.  Otherwies it should take no more than a minute to be ready to receive line (ie orientation) this is the bottleneck because each gun has to be given its own angle by the director/aiming circle, and this has to be set-up.  In quick actions it may be that orientation is done by someone lining up the gun using a prismatic compass 'shot' along the line of each barrel.  This is quicker but will still take some minutes for a battery.
 
Electronic sights as used on L118 by UK and others is much faster, I've read something recently that a UK bty was in action and shooting quicker that an 81mm mortar platoon.
 
Quote    Reply

Carl S       7/20/2007 7:42:17 AM
Some or many of our battery commanders cut the lay time by using reciprical lay (a laid gun sets another) and with two aiming circles.   Carefull prep. by the advance party and the driver/ground guide getting the howitzer poiitioned precisely would reduce the difference between the inital angle & desired angle to a very small error.

Getting back to the quickfire with the M119 its possible the 11 minutes included intial observers message and azimuth of fire/range-elevation computations.  My memery is we were expected to get all that done in much less than ten minutes.  But, its been 25 years since I did full battery ops with a M101.
 
Quote    Reply

FD       7/20/2007 8:34:55 AM
Thanks again for the replys. I have another question. What does the wire do? Is it a line connection between field phones?
 
Quote    Reply

Carl S       7/25/2007 8:56:10 AM
 
Quote    Reply

Carl S       7/25/2007 9:32:08 AM
Once again this web site trashed three pargraphs of my text. Try again,  

Yes the wire connects the field phones.  Also the digital fire control equipment.  The electrical signal from wire is extremely difficult to detect with the singnals intellegence equipment, so its more secure.  And, it is much more reliable.  Althought the digital radio equipment is more reliable than the old analoge radio kit.

On most of our exercises the sigint. people were present & took sadistic pleasure in publishing our positions, transmission times, and message text.  They were invariably accurate and complete, even when were ran our radio communications by the book or better.

We ran three wire circuts in the battery.  A loop which included the mission critical stations, FDC, guns, and CP.  The second was the wire connecting the radios to the attenna farm, which was located 500 - 1000 meters from the guns.  Third was a complete network of wire run to the security outposts, ammo trucks, antenna farm, ect... as well as to the mission essential stations.  When the battery moved the loop circut would go with the advance party & be ready when the main body arrived.  When we begain accquiring the battery digital kit experiments were common with other arraignments.

The battalion comm section automaticly ran wire to the batterys when the postions were expected to be static for more than a hour or two.  Similarlly the divsion artillery HQ also automaticlly ran wire to all the battalions in its control.  These included the: Fire Direction net connecting all FDC in the area,  Conduct of Fire which connected the Foward Observers to the batterys & battalion FDC,  and various administative/logisitcs circuts as required.  The COF was usually wired across the entire divsion artillery group.  Above that the FD circut was considered suffcient for most cases.  In WWII, Korea, or Vietnam it was common for the corps, and often the entire Army artillery to be wired in with a a system of FD circuts for coordinating fires.  At that level the reliability & security over radio was even more important.   A COF above divsion level was rare, but I've run across a few occasions where a local COF was patched into a wire network covering a entire  corps artillery.
 
Quote    Reply

FD       7/25/2007 12:31:08 PM
Carl S,
 
Thanks. I did not realize that there was so much wire being run. So, if you were supporting a movement to contact then if you were going to be in one position for at least 2 hours, then you would probably run wire.
 
Do you know if it is possible to use sigint to locate the battery if they have SINCGARS radios? They might not know what you are saying but would they know where you were?
 
Quote    Reply

Carl S       7/25/2007 9:28:04 PM
Thanks. I did not realize that there was so much wire being run. So, if you were supporting a movement to contact then if you were going to be in one position for at least 2 hours, then you would probably run wire.

***The battery would always run wire.  Bn & above would have wire run within two hours, unless someone was screwing around, or had a good reason not to.  Remember, wire would usually be run by advance partys so a displacement with only average planning would have the essential wire ready as the batterys & HQ occupied their new positions.  The secondary 'nice to have' circuts from HQ were laid in as resources allowed.  

Note that the HQ would have internal  wire circuts.  One for admin & local security,  another for connecting the internal operational sections if they are located in different tents or vehicals.  More wire.
 
Do you know if it is possible to use sigint to locate the battery if they have SINCGARS radios? They might not know what you are saying but would they know where you were?
 

 ***Back in the 1990s, it was susposed to be impossibly difficult.  Currently I have not a clue.  


 
Quote    Reply

FD       7/27/2007 11:38:48 AM
Carl S.
 
Thanks.
 
Quote    Reply

StrategyWorld.com© 1998 - 2008StrategyWorld.com. All rights Reserved. StrategyWorld.com, StrategyPage.com, FYEO, For Your Eyes Only and Al Nofi's CIC are all trademarks of StrategyWorld.com Privacy Policy