Military History | How To Make War | Wars Around the World Rules of Use How to Behave on an Internet Forum
Fighters, Bombers and Recon Discussion Board
   Return to Topic Page
Subject: Su-37 vs. F-22
TankFREAK    11/3/2005 5:39:49 PM
Which do you think is better? The F-22 has stealth features (not completely stealth) and the Su-37 has super-maunverability on it's side (front canards+thrust vectoring). No doubt if there was no stealth and it was an actual dog fight, the Su-37 would undoubtly win. But how effective the F-22's stealth is not completely verified. IMO, i would say that the Su-37 'Terminator' is better, as it has supermanuverability (it can perform the world-reknowned kulbit, which is basically doing a somersault within it's own length). If we knew more about how effective the stealth is on the F-22, i might sway my decision, but at least for the time being, i say the Su-37 is better. What's your take on this?
 
Quote    Reply

Show Only Poster Name and Title     Newest to Oldest
Pages: PREV  1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9   NEXT
skrip00    RE:F-22 clearly superior to the SU-37!   11/8/2005 8:23:10 PM
Yeah, not to mention the F/A-22 has a higher thrust overall. Not to mention supercruise... Yeah, please. The SU-37 doesnt stand a snowball's chance in hell versus an F/A-22. Why do Russian fanboys always think their aircraft are such hot stuff? I mean, I just found out myself, only a small portion of their air force can even fire the vaunted R-77...
 
Quote    Reply

gf0012-aust    RE:F-22 clearly superior to the SU-37!   11/8/2005 9:36:43 PM
" I just found out myself, only a small portion of their air force can even fire the vaunted R-77... " not to mention the fact that only a small portion of their air force can even get decent flying time. - point in case being their fixed wing combat fleet air arm fighters... short intermittent training slots = less competency. /foil hat off
 
Quote    Reply

DarthAmerica    RE:F-22 clearly superior to the SU-37!   11/8/2005 9:47:49 PM
>>>Why do Russian fanboys always think their aircraft are such hot stuff? I mean, I just found out myself, only a small portion of their air force can even fire the vaunted R-77...<<< ---Because they dont have to fight them. And more often than not they dont fight anything. So its hard to grasp things that arent glamorized in Hollywood. Things such as Avionics, Systems of platforms operating in concert design history ect. But the pilots know it. Mostly. The ones who dont, or the dictators who get suckered into pouring their defense budgets into these black holes find out when their pretty aircraft end up as holes in the ground via some modernized 30 year old USAF/USN jet. But again we must remeber the context of this discussion. We are comparing a technology demonstrator against an operational(Dec 2005) killer stealth plane. Go figure.
 
Quote    Reply

Schackleford    RE:F-22 clearly superior to the SU-37!   11/9/2005 9:19:36 AM
"I agree on the stealth thing, it is certainly stealthy to a very good extent, but it's is mostly classified. The Su-37 has TV nozzles as well, it's more manuverable than the F-22, not more than the X-31, but that's completely experimental." Just because you don't see the F-22 making fancy loops and such doesn't make it less maneuvrable. You do however, see the F-22 reach huge speeds with ease, which is vital in a dog fight. The F-22 is lightning fast, accelerates with ease after turning in flight and through all this remains invisible to it's enemies thanks to a tiny RCS. The SU-37 will (if it ever goes operational) be completely unable to match this. The F-22 vs. the SU-37? It will be a slaughter!
 
Quote    Reply

TheGreyBeard    RE:F-22 clearly superior to the SU-37!   11/18/2005 3:20:49 AM
Just a note. Someone said the SU-37 "Is huge...whick doesn't help the RCS..." Actually, RCS has nothing to do with size. The B-2 is far larger than the F-117 but is has a MUCH smaller RCS...just FYI
 
Quote    Reply

buyer    RE:F-22 clearly superior to the SU-37!   12/13/2005 4:44:24 PM
The F-22 is designed not to ever have to get into a dog fight. It cruises supersonic at high altitude and picks off the bad guys from afar without them everknowing you were there until your wing man blows up beside you. If it ever does have to get into a dog fight, the trust vectoring and SA are integrated into the avionics in such a way as to give you max control. All surfaces can engage automatically to achieve your move. I have a slick F-22 Cobra move video. Where do you post them?
 
Quote    Reply

TheArmchairCmd    RE:F-22 clearly superior to the SU-37!   12/13/2005 4:55:18 PM
 
Quote    Reply

aircrafts    RE:F-22 clearly superior to the SU-37!   12/27/2005 7:15:47 PM
never been tested in combat face to face the statement:F-22 clearly superior to the SU-37! is unreasonable. you could speculate though.
 
Quote    Reply

gf0012-aust    RE:F-22 clearly superior to the SU-37!   12/28/2005 1:59:09 AM
"never been tested in combat face to face the statement:F-22 clearly superior to the SU-37! is unreasonable. you could speculate though." speculate on what? a russian aircraft that never went beyond the test platform stage and was abandoned as opposed to an aircraft that now fills 3 squadrons and is now certified for combat? a russian aircraft that was based on gen 4 platform dynamics as opposed to a platform that was new build? a russian platform that even in the best of biggles assessment lacked integration into other force multipliers as opposed to an aircraft that is networked and able to talk to basically anything (even if you just use Link 16 as the basic benchmark of communication capability) The Su-37 was and is a DNS let alone a DNF. You don't have to be too bright to work out which one is better.
 
Quote    Reply

aircrafts    RE:F-22 clearly superior to the SU-37!   12/28/2005 8:51:49 AM
the su 37 is based on su 27, there are many variants of sukhoi on that platform , look if a platform is good enough to make an airplane that is gonna kick f22's ass it doesn't mean it has to be renewed instantly because the americans did. shortly what you 've just said is your own imagination.
 
Quote    Reply
PREV  1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9   NEXT



 Latest
 News
 
 Most
 Read
 
 Most
 Commented
 Hot
 Topics