Military History
|
How To Make War
|
Wars Around the World
Rules of Use
How to Behave on an Internet Forum
Air Defense
Discussion Board
Return to Topic Page
Subject:
air craft being renered obsolete?
usa
4/21/2004 4:16:24 PM
What are the odds that anti aircraft systems will outpace anti anti aricraft systems in the future? ie: Is there any indication that in the future anti air defences will make a leap that will render combat aircraft obsolete?
Quote
Reply
Show Only Poster Name and Title
Newest to Oldest
Thomas
RE:air craft being renered obsolete?
4/22/2004 2:36:21 AM
In my world: Fighter aircraft are PART of the air defence. The russian concept of using primarely SAM's and point-defence interceptors guided by a ground controller with absolute authority - simply isn't flexible enough. A static missile belt will be torn apart - its a question of time. A mobile missile belt does not provide sufficient cover, as the integration problem between the different missile systems is enormeous. reliance on solely ground based radars is to vulnerable on its own against Wild Weasels for instance. To some extend the Soviets were right in creating a special arm: AIR DEFENCE on line with army and navy and air force. But in my view they didn't use this independence to promote the flexibility that is the hallmark of a good air defence system. As You might understand: I'm not AGAINST SAM's, but all for a balanced air defence.
Quote
Reply
B.Smitty
RE:air craft being renered obsolete?
4/22/2004 9:10:02 AM
Directed Energy Weapons (aka LASERS, microwave weapons) may be the only thing that really calls in to question the viability of airpower. An ABL derivative may one day be able to target and near-instantanously destroy groups of aircraft from 200 miles away.
Quote
Reply
interrested 2
RE:air craft being renered obsolete?
4/22/2004 10:14:54 AM
...Any fixed target can be destriyed if enough efford is put in. Any country relying on fixed defesive measures will find that an agressor can focus it's attacking capabilities on one spot overwhelming the defence sam's/radar/THEL whatever. Than a corridor can be formed, the main hubs of (defensive) infrastructure taken out, and there after it's all down hill. Most countries have a top down defensive system, often layered but still top down intergrated. Take out the centre (no nessesarily geographical) and you win. Only a horizontal organised independantly operating aior defense system will continue to remain some sort of thread E.g. A system containing sam's with a kill range of 50 km or so who can "talk" to each other wireless without it being able to be jammed. This system can relocate, redistribute itself again after a coridor has be formed, closing the gap. The decission to do so ( the reforming part) can not be centralized, but at the very lowest level, possible through good training
Quote
Reply
RE:air craft being renered obsolete?
4/29/2004 4:51:38 AM
DEWs will be restricted to LOS system - never BLOS. Physics 101. Concentrated light and the atmosphere do not mix well. So, no, you will not find ground based systems with ranges pushing 200 miles (or half that). As a subnote, hence the ABL program. Atmospheres alot thinner at 32,000 feet. Its not air power thats threatened with obsolesence, its ground-based air defenses. As aircraft get higher and faster, the range with which you can drop munitions (with and without independent propulsion systems) will increase conversely, without ANY additional ordnance development. Ground systems, on the other hand, are restricted by the fact that they must supply their own propellant. Instead of having the advantage of gliding, and using the force of gravity, they must climb, beating that same force. The launch platform is typically static AT LAUNCH (system itself may be mobile, of course), while an airborne launch platform is moving at many hundreds of miles an hour. Look at the JDAM and JSOW - these are dumb bombs with bolt-on glide kits that have 10-30+ mile ranges. Such things simply aren't possible on the ground..
Quote
Reply
Latest
News
Most
Read
Most
Commented
Hot
Topics
INDONESIA: Islamic Terrorists Down But Not Gone
BALKANS: Serbs And Albanians Sort Of Make Peace
MURPHY'S LAW: Searching For Mister Big
COUNTER-TERRORISM: The Other Al Qaeda
WEAPONS: Russia Resists A Revolutionary AK
SPACE: Chinese KillSats Threaten GPS Network
SYRIA: Iran Shows How It Is Done
NAVAL AIR: Replacing Carriers With Cruise Missiles
NAVAL AIR: China Learns From The Masters
ARTILLERY: The Tale Of The North Korean TELs
COUNTER-TERRORISM: A Taliban Cry For Help
MYANMAR: China Tries To Be The Good Guy
WARPLANES: Rafale Fades Some More
MURPHY'S LAW: A Melancholy Milestone For MiG
MURPHY'S LAW: China Bans Military Hotrods
KURDISH WAR: The Threat From Syria And Iran
YEMEN: Death Squads Gone Wild
WEAPONS: SEALs Succumb To Sig Sauer
SUPPORT: The Chinese Air Force Underground
MORALE: The Neo-Red Army Steps Out
LIBYA: Power To The Wrong People
SUDAN: The Forever War In Darfur
AIR DEFENSE: Russian Tech Fails To Protect Syria
CHINA: Cracking Down On North Korea
MURPHY'S LAW: North Korea And The High Tech Horror
SPACE: Replacing Satellites With Software
ATTRITION: The Cost Of Good Intentions
NIGERIA: We Know Where Your Family Lives
WINNING: The North Korean Solution
SEA TRANSPORTATION: Joint High Speed Vessels
Subscribe to Our RSS Feed
WARS Syria: Iran Shows How It Is Done
Naval Air: Replacing Carriers With Cruise Missiles
Naval Air: China Learns From The Masters
Artillery: The Tale Of The North Korean TELs
Counter-Terrorism: A Taliban Cry For Help
Warplanes: Rafale Fades Some More
Weapons: SEALs Succumb To Sig Sauer
WARS Myanmar: China Tries To Be The Good Guy
Murphy's Law: A Melancholy Milestone For MiG
Support: The Chinese Air Force Underground
Murphy's Law: China Bans Military Hotrods
WARS Kurdish War: The Threat From Syria And Iran
Morale: The Neo-Red Army Steps Out
WARS Yemen: Death Squads Gone Wild
Air Defense: Russian Tech Fails To Protect Syria
WARS Libya: Power To The Wrong People
WARS Sudan: The Forever War In Darfur
WARS China: Cracking Down On North Korea
Murphy's Law: North Korea And The High Tech Horror
Space: Replacing Satellites With Software
Warplanes: Another Old Warrior Too Good To Replace
Attrition: The Cost Of Good Intentions
Winning: The North Korean Solution
Sea Transportation: Joint High Speed Vessels
Air Defense: So What If It Does Not Work
NAVAL AIR: Replacing Carriers With Cruise Missiles
AIR DEFENSE: Russian Tech Fails To Protect Syria
WINNING: China Counts Its Victories
WARPLANES: Rafale Fades Some More
SEA TRANSPORTATION: Joint High Speed Vessels
YEMEN: Death Squads Gone Wild
COUNTER-TERRORISM: A Taliban Cry For Help
CHINA: Cracking Down On North Korea
INFORMATION WARFARE: All Hate All The Time
ARTILLERY: The Tale Of The North Korean TELs
INDIA-PAKISTAN: Terrorists Win A big Election
INDONESIA: Islamic Terrorists Down But Not Gone
COUNTER-TERRORISM: The Other Al Qaeda
SUPPORT: The Chinese Air Force Underground
ATTRITION: The Cost Of Good Intentions
MURPHY'S LAW: North Korea And The High Tech Horror
WINNING: The North Korean Solution
AFGHANISTAN: Civilians Fighting The Taliban And Winning
MORALE: Missile Men Lose Their Mojo
WEAPONS: SEALs Succumb To Sig Sauer
Dirty Little Links: News Links.
Naval Air: Replacing Carriers With Cruise Missiles
Who's Winning: China Counts Its Victories
Artillery: The Tale Of The North Korean TELs
Counter-Terrorism Operations: A Taliban Cry For Help
India: Terrorists Win A big Election
China: Cracking Down On North Korea
Counter-Terrorism Operations: The Other Al Qaeda
Indonesia: Islamic Terrorists Down But Not Gone
Books of Interest
The Guns at Last Light: The War in Western Europe, 1944-1945 (Liberation Trilogy)
Fallujah Awakens: Marines, Sheikhs, and the Battle Against al Qaeda (Blue and Gold)
SPECIAL OPERATIONS IN THE AMERICAN REVOLUTION
Bunker Hill: A City, a Siege, a Revolution
The Way of the Knife: The CIA, a Secret Army, and a War at the Ends of the Earth
From Amazon
News
How To Make War
Wars Around The World
Austin Bay's On Point
StrategyTalk
Dirty Little Secrets
Features
Al Nofi's CIC
Prediction Market
Wargames
Measure of Respect
On War and Warfare
Videos
Photos
Jokes
Community
Military Discussion Boards
Military Jokes
Military Photos
Military Book Reviews
Military Movie Reviews
StrategyPage
Subscribe
Login
Feedback
About Us
Search
Account Manager
Advertise With Us
Search