Afghanistan Article Index : Current 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Why Who
 Latest
 News
 
 Most
 Read
 
 Most
 Commented
 Hot
 Topics
Something Is Happening Down There
   Next Article → SPECIAL OPERATIONS: Beating The Bodyguard Blues

July 19, 2009: The U.S. Marine advance into Helmand province is being slowed down by the new Rules Of Engagement (ROE), which forbid the use of bombs or missiles in any situation where there might be civilians. The Taliban will typically spend the night, or longer, in a village or walled compound, and that's where U.S. troops will typically trap them. But bombs and missiles cannot be used on these places, so U.S. troops have to besiege the place, or just move on, leaving the Taliban alone. Some marines get creative, like having the jet fighters or bombs make a high speed pass over the Taliban held buildings. The fearsome noise will sometimes unnerve the Taliban and cause a surrender, but not as much as it used to. Another favorite tactic is having the fighter (usually an F-16 or F-18) come in low and use its 20mm cannon. But these air craft only carry a few seconds worth of ammunition. Moreover, having these jets fly that low makes them liable to crashing (this has happened, at least once) or being brought down by enemy fire (has not happened yet). But the cannon fire sometimes induces the Taliban to give up, or try to flee.

The other option, when you have the Taliban cornered, and using human shields, is to go in and fight them room-to-room. That gets more Americans killed, as well as putting the Afghan civilians in danger. This room-to-room tactic has not been used much, as commanders don't want to take the heat for losing troops in that kind of fighting. If there is a lot more of this house to house fighting, and civilians get killed, the ROE may be changed again to forbid any kind of combat if civilians are present. This reduces the anger of locals from civilian deaths involving U.S. forces, but makes it much more difficult to hunt down and destroy the Taliban gunmen. The Taliban are still vulnerable, as they have to move in order to operate, and the Afghan Army or police can often negotiate a surrender, or go in and root them out by force. But the best troops available for chasing down the Taliban gunmen are the U.S. and NATO ones.

It's not just the Taliban who are being shut down in Helmand. The heroin operations are a major target, as are corrupt Afghan cops (who often set themselves up as bandit kings, shaking down criminals and ordinary civilians, and often making peace deals with the Taliban.) The district commanders (there are 398 districts in the 34 provinces) are sometimes corrupt as well, or not willing to risk losing the fight it they go after a rogue police unit. The marines have brought in better trained and led police (the questionable cops are sent away for retraining, or discharge).

The battle against the drug gangs is a complicated one. A lot of money is involved, and the drug lords are pretty smart. They now keep a lot of their processing (opium into morphine or heroin) labs mobile. The vehicles travel with armed guards, but force is a last resort. The security detachment is also armed with a lot of cash, and the first weapon to be deployed is a bribe. That usually works. But the U.S. intelligence troops are after the drug gangs now, and this makes concealment more difficult. The U.S. military isn't releasing any play-by-play of these operations, lest they provide useful information to the enemy. It won't be until the end of August that an initial assessment is possible, and not until the end of the year until one can check the trends in wholesale and retail prices for heroin. As Afghanistan heroin production grew since the 1990s, the world supply has doubled, and prices have come down by about 50 percent. More people are using, and dying from, heroin. And now we can add many of the victims of the fighting in southern Afghanistan to that toll.

The intense combat in Helmand, and elsewhere, has bumped up the casualty rate. Foreign troops are headed for a record number of casualties (possibly 800 or more, including about a hundred dead) for the year. There are also heavier casualties for Afghan soldiers and police, but not as high as the foreign troops and Taliban. Going after key targets in Helmand province, the source of most of the world's heroin supply, goes to the heart of Taliban power: drug money. The drug gangs and the Taliban are partners, just as they were back in the 1990s, when the heroin trade got established in Afghanistan under Taliban protection. With the drug money gone, the Taliban would lose most of their ability to put a lot of gunmen into action each Summer. The heavy Taliban use of suicide and roadside bombs has turned most of the civilian population against them. Thus the push to limit the use of American weapons that can kill or injure civilians. But in Afghanistan, "hearts and minds" work a little differently. Afghanistan is the poorest nation in Eurasia, and most of the population lives on the edge of disaster (one or two bad crops and there used to be massive death tolls from starvation). While the foreign food aid eliminates the ancient threat of starvation, and Afghans know where that food aid comes from, there is a tendency among Afghans to side with whoever is strongest. This was one reason the Taliban were driven out of power in two months in late 2001. There is no shame, to an Afghan, in switching sides. For an Afghan, it's the smart thing to do. It's how you survive. It's how it's been done for thousands of years.

In southeast Afghanistan, NATO and Afghan troops are disrupting Taliban operations by raiding known Taliban safe houses and operating areas. This is part of the effort to damage the network of roadside and suicide bomb builders and those who finance and direct them.

July 18, 2009:  A U.S. F-15E fighter bomber crashed in eastern Afghanistan at about 3:15 AM. The two man crew was killed. These aircraft normally operate at 20,000 feet (6,500 meters) to avoid ground fire. But at that altitude, you have to watch out for the many mountains and ridges in the area that are over 3,000 meters high. The U.S. Air Force is conducting an investigation.

July 16, 2009: The Taliban released a video of an American soldiers who went missing on June 30th, and was believed to have been captured by local tribesmen, and sold to the Taliban. The Taliban are now demanding that the U.S. get out of southeast Afghanistan and not attack the Taliban there, or the soldier will be killed. The U.S. has offered $25,000 reward for information on the whereabouts of the soldier, and is scouring the area looking for him. This is the first U.S. soldier ever captured by the Taliban since U.S. forces entered Afghanistan in late 2001. The circumstances of how this soldier was taken are murky. He says on the video that he was grabbed when he lagged behind while on patrol. But initial reports were that he was drinking with Afghan soldiers, and left the base with them, and then disappeared. It will be a while before the true story comes out.

Next Article → SPECIAL OPERATIONS: Beating The Bodyguard Blues
  
Show Only Poster Name and Title     Newest to Oldest
Pages: 1 2 3 4   NEXT
trenchsol       7/19/2009 10:58:02 AM
Perhaps aircraft gunship (AC-130) could flush the Taliban out ? They can deliver accurate dire and don't use bombs or missiles.
 
DG

 
Quote    Reply

SOP919F3    De Facto CIC   7/19/2009 7:11:44 PM
Rules of engagement are made public (look everyone, we're actually good people), something that used to be classified.  The Taliban are smarter than our government leaders and know how to fight us.  The military canceled the orders to Afghanistan belonging to Maj. Stefan Frederick Cook, who challenged in court the "legitimacy" of the Commander In Chief, something we are NOT supposed to talk about because it deals with the Constitution and even though we swear to "support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic" bearing true faith and allegiance to the same, we are just to STFU and obey or they cut our funding.
 
So now we have a soldier (Pfc. Bowe R. Bergdahl) who is captured and the pentagon (remember Haditha?) is looking for ways to smear him to hide the obvious:
(1) Both our hands are tied behind our backs, thanks to the publicized ROE
(2) US military personnel may be tried as war criminals because according to Maj Cook's case: "without a legitimate president as commander-in-chief, members of the U.S. military in overseas actions could be determined to be "war criminals and subject to prosecution. (You may be a war criminal even if you're following orders, which have no legality from the top)  Geneva Conventions?? Fuggetaboutit, you don't qualify.
(3)  Returning to the days of Jimmy Carter when the morality was in the toilet.
 
As a side note:
Maj Cook (an engineer) was fired by his civilian employer Simtech.   According to the CEO of Simtech Inc., a private company contracted by the Defense Security Services, the federal government has compelled the termination of Cook
Let me translate, fire him or lose the contract.  Yes, the Chicago mobsters know how to deal with those who dare to think and act.     h**p://www.wnd.com/index.php?fa=PAGE.view&pageId=104208
 
All this of course places the Taliban in an advantage:  If they somehow manage to safely get Pfc. Bowe R. Bergdahl out and headed home promising to do the same for others who (like Cook) object to the legality of the orders, what then would be the outcome?  My guess is that they'd win a huge propaganda stunt and cause confusion in the UCMJ system when civilian lawyers like Dr. Orly Taitz get involved just as they did with the "Haditha" Marines.

 
 
 
 
Quote    Reply

SOP919F3    edit, delete   7/19/2009 8:33:31 PM
About the censoring of my post:
 
The AP (9 hours ago) released the name, base, and home town of the missing () soldier  - the source was the Pentagon.
 
As far as the other                                             deleted parts, it is after all, a strategy based on opinion that the other side could take because of our precarious situation, something that needs addressed.
 
Quote    Reply

WarNerd       7/19/2009 9:18:07 PM

Perhaps aircraft gunship (AC-130) could flush the Taliban out ? They can deliver accurate dire and don't use bombs or missiles.

Doubtful, the ROE sounds more like "No fire for effect when civilians are present". 
The best solution would be to assign a Predator drone to each location to watch for and track the Taliban when they leave.  Predators are in short supply however, so an alternative approach would be to have a dependable(?) Afghan Army unit set up a temporary observation point in a neighboring compound to do the job.
 
But I suspect the main strategy is to go after the money / drugs to force the Taliban to allow themselves to be engaged in their defense.
 
Quote    Reply

Nasty German Idiot       7/19/2009 9:29:52 PM
 
Quote    Reply

flyingarty    A-10   7/19/2009 10:26:02 PM
The A-10's Avenger cannon should do the trick, but, of course, they will ban that too. Of course the taliban follows all the rules-geesh!
 
Quote    Reply

jak267       7/20/2009 11:19:07 AM
Obama and McChrystal's Vietnam.
 
Quote    Reply

Mike From Brielle       7/20/2009 11:41:52 AM
More Stingrays needed, probably should have saturated the area between the line of advance and those areas that the Taliban would likely use as sanctuary (would get into a lot of gun fights and just like going house to house could involve casualties), but this is hindsight.  Pre reconnaissance would have to have been truly outstanding.
 
Maybe we should ask the Afghan Govt' (Karsai) to offer an amnesty with temporary paid detention (paid to and for their families) program for any gun on the orther side to surender in a situation where civilians could get hurt.  This might take the onus off the allies a little when CAS has to be performed. The ones who won't take the offer are hard core and you wait em out and kill em (other than mop up sometimes operational criteria may prevent waiting).  The ones who take the offer may be smart hard  core and you biometric them and maybe even occasionally place passive rf  beacons in them (like dogs-for drones or scamp to pick up) then stingray them.  Maybe you send the ones who were just in it for the money to trade school.  Just a thought.
 
Quote    Reply

Chris       7/20/2009 11:55:38 AM

The A-10's Avenger cannon should do the trick, but, of course, they will ban that too. Of course the taliban follows all the rules-geesh!

I agree.  The F-16 and F-18 are too fast, don't carry enough ammo, and can't loiter enough.  More attack assets like the A-10 is what makes the most sense. 
 
Quote    Reply

YelliChink       7/20/2009 2:01:10 PM


Some translation please?
 
Quote    Reply
1 2 3 4   NEXT