Military History
|
How To Make War
|
Wars Around the World
Rules of Use
How to Behave on an Internet Forum
Air Defense
Discussion Board
Return to Topic Page
Subject:
Iron Dome Spoils The Hamas Surprise Attack
SYSOP
11/20/2012 5:37:21 AM
Quote
Reply
Show Only Poster Name and Title
Newest to Oldest
Pages:
1
2
human1
rockets
11/21/2012 3:33:00 PM
At first, It looked like rocket from Gaza were declining but on Tuesday 189 rockets were fired.
So I wonder if this analysis is still valid ? We will see the result of Wednesday.
Hamas places fake rockets to lure Israeli fighters
Quote
Reply
Don Vandervelde
get real
11/21/2012 11:24:09 PM
Nerd, this is war, not a football game. A level playing field and fair play have no place here. If Hamas barbarians insists on destroying their own people in order to generate sympathy, its on them, plus it shortens the war which has gone on way too many decades already. War should be avoided, but when it's inevitable, it should be won. In the end fewer people will be killed.
Quote
Reply
voland
11/24/2012 9:04:36 PM
@American God: two mis-attributions. "They never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity" is by Abba Eban. "useful idiots" is from Lenin's works. other than that, no objections.
Quote
Reply
WarNerd
11/25/2012 2:39:28 AM
Nerd, this is war, not a football game. A level playing field and fair play have no place here. If Hamas barbarians insists on destroying their own people in order to generate sympathy, its on them, plus it shortens the war which has gone on way too many decades already. War should be avoided, but when it's inevitable, it should be won. In the end fewer people will be killed.
Vandervelde – Pay attention
1. The point of war is not a body count, it is to impose your will on the enemy. It is psychological, not physical. Yes, a body count can help bring it about, but only if the vast majority of the bodies are the right people.
2. This war is about global public opinion, which is the same as the above, but on a larger stage.
3. Lastly, to win you have to break the cycle of revenge. Even if you eliminate Hamas by killing 10 Palestinians for every Hamas member, say about 40,000 people out of a population of 1,700,000, you will lose because something new, much larger, and probably more radical, will be created from the demand for revenge of the relatives of the innocent victims. Yes, the Palestinians already hate the Israelis, but there is a difference between hatred and a need for revenge. Most Palestinians want a decent life more than revenge, but they are trapped with the radicals. Minimize the innocent victims, minimize the next cycle of revenge.
Having said all that, I think we can agree that Israel stopped too soon. Benjamin Netanyahu and Likud will probably pay for it in January elections, if Likud doesn’t drop him earlier. It will be interesting to see what comes next
Quote
Reply
voland
11/25/2012 2:19:41 PM
@warNerd
3. Lastly, to win you have to break the cycle of revenge.
you break the cycle of revenge by depriving the opponent of the ability to engage in it. see my reply yo (1).
Quote
Reply
voland
11/25/2012 2:27:26 PM
@warNerd
1. The point of war is not a body count, it is to impose your will on the enemy. It is psychological, not physical.
...
2. This war is about global public opinion, which is the same as the above, but on a larger stage.
...
3. Lastly, to win you have to break the cycle of revenge
this is embarrassing. the post had 3 quotes and only the last one was picked up. reformatted text and re-posting.
(1)
it is, first and foremost, physical. that is what makes psychological acceptance of defeat possible. Carthage is a good example. Jewish War (destruction of the second temple) is another one. in the first case, there was nothing left to resist. in the second one, the possibility of resistance was destroyed. Tet offensive outcome was unique in its incongruity: military defeat made into a victory. but i agree that body count is irrelevant.
(2)
nope. public opinion is relevant only when the country is too small to influence decision makers. military dismemberment of Serbia was possible. but Russia? no way. public opinion of Russia's backing of Assad is not favorable but neither the brits not the french are chomping at the bit like they did on Libya.
(3)
you break the cycle of revenge by depriving the opponent of the ability to engage in it. see my reply yo (1).
Quote
Reply
WarNerd
11/26/2012 4:44:23 AM
(1)
it is, first and foremost, physical. that is what makes psychological acceptance of defeat possible. Carthage is a good example. Jewish War (destruction of the second temple) is another one. in the first case, there was nothing left to resist. in the second one, the possibility of resistance was destroyed. Tet offensive outcome was unique in its incongruity: military defeat made into a victory. but i agree that body count is irrelevant.
You might want to read the works Sun Tzu and Clausewitz. They are usually considered experts, and don’t agree with you.
(2) nope. public opinion is relevant only when the country is too small to influence decision makers. military dismemberment of Serbia was possible. but Russia? no way. public opinion of Russia's backing of Assad is not favorable but neither the brits not the french are chomping at the bit like they did on Libya.
The entire world is not a
small country
that can be ignored.
(3)
you break the cycle of revenge by depriving the opponent of the ability to engage in it. see my reply yo (1).
That only leaves them unable to respond immediately, but you have to continuously act to keep them from accumulating the capacity. After the 2006 invasion of Gaza the missiles and artillery attacks stopped for a short while, but in 2012 they were hitting Tel Aviv. To stop it permanently you either have to either reduce the desire to attack, or eliminate the entire population.
Quote
Reply
1
2
Latest
News
Most
Read
Most
Commented
Hot
Topics
SPECIAL OPERATIONS: Ukrainian Improvised Air-Defense Network
AIR DEFENSE: Where the Patriot Missile Batteries Are
AIR DEFENSE: Never Enough Air Defense Missiles
SUBMARINES: US Colombia SSBNs Behind Schedule
PROCUREMENT: Neutral Switzerland Upgrades Its Military
PROCUREMENT: Neutral Switzerland Upgrades Its Military
CHINA: China April 2024 Update
SUBMARINES: New Submarines for Norway
WEAPONS: Russia Running Out of Antique Weapons
SOMALIA: Somalia April 2024
ARTILLERY: New Iranian Weapons
INTELLIGENCE: NATO Suspects a Threat
ATTRITION: Russia fires on Ukrainian Fakes
NAVAL AIR: Tritons Assemble
WEAPONS: South Korean Arms Exports to the Middle East
LIBYA: Libya April Update
ARTILLERY: Russia Bombards Ukraine With North Korean Missiles
WARPLANES: South Korea’s Troubled KF-21 Jet Fighter Project
AIR WEAPONS: Drones Dominate Ukrainian Battlefield
SUBMARINES: Ukraine Obtains Anti-Submarine Weapons
MURPHY'S LAW: Nationwide Impact of Ukraine War in Russia
STRATEGIC WEAPONS: American ARRW Missile Tested
SURFACE FORCES : Vasily Bykov class Corvettes
SPECIAL OPERATIONS: Tatar Rebels in Crimea
PROCUREMENT: China Supercharges Military Spending
ARMOR: M1A2SEP3 Tank Paradox
AIR DEFENSE: Russia Seeks Answers
ARTILLERY: HIMARS Prevails Against Russians
ARTILLERY: Chinese-Truck Mounted Artillery
SURFACE FORCES : Zumwalt Class Destroyers Find a Purpose
Subscribe to Our RSS Feed
Air Defense: Where the Patriot Missile Batteries Are
Special Operations: Ukrainian Improvised Air-Defense Network
Special Operations: Ukrainian Improvised Air-Defense Network
Air Defense: Never Enough Air Defense Missiles
Submarines: US Colombia SSBNs Behind Schedule
WARS China: China April 2024 Update
Weapons: Russia Running Out of Antique Weapons
Procurement: Neutral Switzerland Upgrades Its Military
Procurement: Neutral Switzerland Upgrades Its Military
Submarines: New Submarines for Norway
On PointIsrael's Airspace Defense Victory: Credit Reagan's SDI
Artillery: New Iranian Weapons
Intelligence: NATO Suspects a Threat
WARS Somalia: Somalia April 2024
Naval Air: Tritons Assemble
Attrition: Russia fires on Ukrainian Fakes
WEAPONS: Russia Running Out of Antique Weapons
AIR DEFENSE: Where the Patriot Missile Batteries Are
CHINA: China April 2024 Update
SUBMARINES: New Submarines for Norway
WEAPONS: South Korean Arms Exports to the Middle East
NAVAL AIR: Tritons Assemble
ATTRITION: Russia fires on Ukrainian Fakes
INTELLIGENCE: NATO Suspects a Threat
ARTILLERY: New Iranian Weapons
SOMALIA: Somalia April 2024
PROCUREMENT: Neutral Switzerland Upgrades Its Military
PROCUREMENT: Neutral Switzerland Upgrades Its Military
SUBMARINES: US Colombia SSBNs Behind Schedule
AIR DEFENSE: Never Enough Air Defense Missiles
SPECIAL OPERATIONS: Ukrainian Improvised Air-Defense Network
SPECIAL OPERATIONS: Ukrainian Improvised Air-Defense Network
FORCES: Israeli Haredi Riots
Air Defense: Where the Patriot Missile Batteries Are
News
How To Make War
Wars Around The World
Austin Bay's On Point
StrategyTalk
Dirty Little Secrets
Features
Al Nofi's CIC
Videos
Photos
Jokes
Community
Military Discussion Boards
Military Jokes
Military Photos
Military Book Reviews
StrategyPage
Account Manager
Login
Feedback
About Us
Search
Advertise With Us
Search