August 23, 2008:
One reason many European nations are
reluctant to let their troops engage the enemy in Iraq, or Afghanistan, is that
they fear the outcome will not be up to the task. Over a decade of shrinking
budgets has meant less money for realistic training. There are also equipment
shortages. The net result is several layers of leadership that are really not
well prepared for a shooting war. The leaders of these nations have also been
warned about this by their own special operations troops, who have seen combat
in Afghanistan. Most of these operations have been kept secret, as is normal
for this sort of thing. But the commandos from these different nations had
opportunities to exchange notes, and it was generally agreed that most post
Cold War European nations had let most of their combat troops down. The special
operations forces were hardly cut at all, as they were considered vital for
counter-terrorism, or any kind of military emergency that might come up. The
spec ops guys were dismayed at what was happening to the levels of training and
equipment in the rest of the armed
forces, and knew it could mean disaster if these guys were sent into combat.
Now that's starting to happen, and the
results are not pretty. For example, several Czech helicopter pilots, when told
they were going to Afghanistan, basically said no. Not unless they got more
training, and helicopters that could handle that kind of tricky flying. The
crew of an Italian helicopter gunship was recently sent home because they
refused to fire in combat. No one will say exactly what happened there, but
that sort of thing is usually the result of poor preparation, and leadership.
And then there's the recent ambush of a French patrol, which resulted in ten
French paratroopers killed. Most of the casualties occurred because the troops had
not practiced dealing with ambushes, and the way the Taliban operate. Worse,
the French troops were trapped under fire for many hours, long past the time
when air cover or ground reinforcements should have arrived. Again, this has
all the marks of bad leadership and poor training.
The well trained and equipped volunteer
troops (particularly the American, British, Canadian, Australian and commandos
of all nations) make it look easy. But it isn't. Lots of training, lots of
practice, and decades developing combat leadership, is what it takes. Some
nations are now faced with the need to repair some of the damage cause by that
post Cold War euphoria and budget cutting.