Support: Long Eyes That Never Sleep


April 8, 2015: The U.S. Army recently added the Israeli SkyStar 180 observation balloon (aerostat) system to the list of those approved for army use. The army has been using aerostats for combat support since 2003 and was impressed by how well SkyStar worked as a mobile system. Carried on a truck and operated by a two man crew it can set up in less than an hour. The aerostat can be inflated and sent up to 300-400 meters (910-1240 feet) altitude. The aerostat carries a 20 kg (66 pound) payload of sensors (day/night cameras or a communications relay to extend the range of military or police radios).  Power is provided via the cable anchoring the aerostat and a generator on the truck or some other nearby source. Every 72 hours the aerostat is brought down for maintenance (takes less than an hour). In Israel SkyStar 180 is used by military and police and is offered as an export item. There is also a SkyStar 300 which uses a larger aerostat that lifts a 43 kg payload, which can include a radar. Israeli manufacturers provide radars for this. These radars are also made in the United States. The U.S. Army began using the AN/ZPY-1 Starlite lightweight radars in some aerostats back in 2012. This combination was very popular in Afghanistan. The Starlite radar weighs 29.5 kg (65 pounds), occupies 34 cc (1.2 cubic feet), uses 750 watts of power and costs about $2.3 million each. The Starlite was originally designed for use in the army's 1.5 ton MQ-1C Sky Warrior UAV. Starlite can deliver photo quality black and white radar images of what is down there, in any weather. The army has developed software that enables the Starlite images to be transmitted to existing army video terminals, and automatically appear on electronic versions of standard army maps. Starlite is used in combination with vidcams and heat sensors (infrared or thermal).

Aerostats are helium filled balloons shaped to remain stationary in bad weather. These aerostats have become as important as UAVs in keeping an eye on the battlefield. As popular as UAVs are, aerostats provided most of the aerial surveillance over Afghanistan and many other trouble spots (like Gaza, the West Bank, and southern Lebanon). The larger UAVs are popular mainly for their mobility and persistence (the ability to stay in the air, over a particular area, for a long time). Predator and Global Hawk can stay in the air for over 24 hours at a time. Controllers and observers, operating via satellite link from bases in the U.S., see that the video and radar images get passed on to the people that need them. But the military has found that "stationary UAVs" (aerostats or tall towers) not only do the job but do it a lot cheaper (under $1,000 an hour, mostly for maintenance, repairs, and personnel to monitor the sensors) and stay airborne nearly all the time. Compare this to Predator, which costs $6,000 an hour to fly, and Global Hawk, which is 4-5 times more than that. Global Hawk is so expensive partly because of the high end sensors used. Not everyone needs the high flying Global Hawk or even a Predator. They just need a way to keep an eye on a large area (like a chunk of the Syrian, Iranian, or Pakistani border or the area surrounding a base) 24/7. Americans call these PTDS (Persistent Threat Detection Systems) and mount the sensor package on aerostats or towers as a much cheaper alternative to mobile UAVs.

All this is a recent development. In 2004 the U.S. Army sent its first 22 aerostats to Iraq and Afghanistan. These aerostats operated at about 330 meters (a thousand feet) up, tethered by a cable that provides power and communications to the day and night cameras up there. The big problem was ground fire from rifles and machine-guns. Hostile gunmen liked using the aerostats as targets. Rifle fire would not destroy the aerostats but did cause them to be brought down more frequently for repairs. Normally, the aerostats can stay up for 30 days at a time but the bullet damage have some of them coming down every few days. The PTDS surveillance systems mounted on tall steel towers also suffer gunfire damage but rarely any that disables the equipment.

The first army aerostats in Iraq were used to help defend offshore oil facilities from attack by terrorist speedboats. Those early systems used a 75.2 meter (233 foot) long, helium filled, unmanned aerostat equipped with radar and other sensors. These aerostats were about 2.5 times the size as the more familiar advertising blimp. Aerostats are blimp like vehicles designed to always turn into the wind and stay in the same place. These larger aerostats were originally designed to detect cruise missiles but were soon replaced by smaller and cheaper aerostat systems currently in use. The Israeli SkyStar looks more like a spherical balloon, but it does have a special shape to it that helps keep it stable in winds.

These smaller PTDS systems were much cheaper, less than five million dollars each, and the army has bought several hundred of them. An aerostat operating at 330 meters can see out to about sixty kilometers. The smaller towers shorten that range quite a bit. The ten meter (31 foot tower) can see out to eleven kilometers, the 20 meter tower out to 16 kilometers, and 26 meter tower out to 20 kilometers. The ten meter tower is adequate for most situations, which usually involve guarding a base.

Israel also produces the larger EL/M-2083 Aerostat radars. These systems can hover at 3,000 meters altitude and carry up to two tons of sensors. These blimps can stay up for about 30 days at a time before it has to be brought down for maintenance on its radars. Often, two radars are carried. One is a surveillance radar, the other is a precision track and illumination radar (PTIR). The surveillance radar provides long-range coverage (about 500 kilometers for the EL/M-2083) while the PTIR, which is a steerable system capable of tracking multiple targets, can focus in on items of interest.

 Aerostat system costs vary from $5 million to over $100 million each, depending on the size of the aerostat and the capabilities of the radar and other sensors. Aerostats work. Kuwait had one in 1990, and the ground radar spotted the Iraqis as soon as they crossed the border. The EL/M-2083 costs about $20 million each. Israel itself has bought six of them.





Help Keep Us From Drying Up

We need your help! Our subscription base has slowly been dwindling.

Each month we count on your contributions. You can support us in the following ways:

  1. Make sure you spread the word about us. Two ways to do that are to like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.
  2. Subscribe to our daily newsletter. We’ll send the news to your email box, and you don’t have to come to the site unless you want to read columns or see photos.
  3. You can contribute to the health of StrategyPage.
Subscribe   Contribute   Close