by Walter Scheidel
Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2025. Pp. vi, 316.
Notes, biblio., index. $29.95 / £25.00. ISBN:0691236658
Questioning the Western Canon in a Modern World
“The Oxford English Dictionary defines it as a 'chiefly colloquial' term meant to refer to 'The past or a past event considered as no longer relevant, important or interesting'.” (p. 3)
Like so many things in our culture, “Ancient History” has been extensively weaponized in the service of political ideology. The patriarchal slave-holding societies of Greece and Rome, as viewed through their elitist literary traditions, are held up as the sources of an idealized “Western Civilization,” celebrated as inherently superior to Other (i.e., non-White) civilizations. There is a proliferation of bogus theories that attribute the “Fall of Rome” to whatever current social trend the speaker dislikes. This brilliant little book delivers a powerful antidote to that sort of brain poison.
The academic study of ancient history, and particularly of the classical languages (Latin and Greek), is dying a slow painful death, as schools and universities shift resources to subjects considered to have more popular appeal to students and donors, or more promising vocational prospects.
The book consists of,
Introduction: That’s Ancient History!
1. Worldmaking: How We Got Here
2. Worldbreaking: Where We Went Wrong
3. Going Global: What We Should Do
4. Losing Classics: Why We Need To Move On
Conclusion: Can We Do It?
Scheidel concludes the book on a rather positive note:
“If even ’ancient history’, proverbial for its presumed irrelevance, manages to reinvent itself as a forward-looking endeavor ready to explain our roots, meet the needs of an increasingly interconnected planet, embrace diversity, and contribute to a more equitable vision of humankind, there is hope for everyone. (p. 250)
Schiedel writes with a wry sense of humor that is all too rare in academic publications. His mastery of the subject is broad and deep. What is Ancient History? is a challenging book. Many classicists will disagree vigorously with the argument it presents. It will be read with interest by anyone who cares deeply about how the modern world deals with the ancient world.
Walter Schiedel is Professor of Classics at Stanford University. His previous books include Escape from Rome (2021) and The Great Leveler: Violence and the History of Inequality from the Stone Age to the Twenty-First Century (2025). He has also held positions at the Universities of Vienna, Cambridge, and Chicago, and visiting appointments in Paris, Innsbruck, New York, Abu Dhabi, Copenhagen and Zurich.
– Mike Markowitz
---///---
Our Reviewer: Mike Markowitz is an historian and wargame designer. He writes a monthly column for CoinWeek and is a member of the ADBC (Association of Dedicated Byzantine Collectors). His previous reviews include The Emperor and the Elephant, Tiberius, The Roman Empire and World History, Leadership in the Ancient World: Concepts, Models, Theories, A History of the Greek World from 479 to 323 B.C., Commanders and Command in the Roman Republic and Early Empire, Love, War and Diplomacy: The Discovery of the Amarna Letters and the Bronze Age World They Revealed, Nikephoros II Phokas (912-969): The White Death of the Saracens, 1453: The Conquest and Tragedy of Constantinople, Naval Warfare under the Byzantine Empire: From Justinian I to the Fourth Crusade, Carthage, A New History, Constantinople: Capital of Byzantium, War and Community in Late Antiquity, Ancient Warfare: The Basics, and Portraits of Generalship and Authority in the Age of Justinian.
---///---
Note: What is Ancient History? is also available in audio & e-editions.
StrategyPage reviews are published in cooperation with The New York Military Affairs Symposium
www.nymas.org